QuizTime(65) which Sahabi was called as "The Crying Sahabi" ?

 

QuizTime(65) which Sahabi was called as "The Crying Sahabi" ?

 

 

Ans:  Tha'labah Ibn Abdur-Rahmaan(R.a) He was called because of one Fabricated or Daeef Hadith.

 

 

There are many videos and articles floating around the internet and well known Islamic youtube channels(https://youtu.be/kRN1G-THuqY) sharing this fabaricated or daeef Hadith about a sahabi and millions of people liking, talking, sharing, getting emotional, crying, tears flowing out. All Wasted!

 

 

This story was related in full by Abu Nu’aym Al-Asbahaani in Ma’rifat As-Sahaabah, it was also mentioned by As-Suyooti in Al-Laali’ Al-Masnoo’ah fee Al-Ahaadeeth Al-Mawdhoo’ah, and it was mentioned by Ibn 'Arraaq in Tanzeeh Ash-Sharee’ah Al-Marfoo’ ‘an Al-Ahaadeeth Ash-Shanee’ah Al-Mawdhoo’ah"; and he ruled the story to be weak.

 

 

 

Also, Ibn Hajar quoted it in Al-Isaabah fi Tamyeez As-Sahaabah; then he said, “Ibn Mandah said after he narrated it briefly, Mansoor was the only one who narrated it.' I say, 'He is weak, and his Shaykh is even weaker than him. The context indicates the weakness of this information because the revelation of the verse {Your Lord has not taken leave of you [O Muhammad] nor has He detested [you].} [Quran 93:3] was before the migration without any difference of opinion.'” 

 

 

So the story is either weak or fabricated.

 

 

“O believers, if an evildoer brings you any news, verify ˹it˺”

[Al-Qur’an ch 49 Verse 6]

 

 

More details check this Hadith Isnad: 

 

 

The story of Tha‘labah who saw a woman doing ghusl, and died from fear of Allah.

 

 

Link:  https://islamqa.info/en/answers/145797/the-story-of-thalabah-who-saw-a-woman-doing-ghusl-and-died-from-fear-of-allah

 

 

Allah knows the best .

 

By Mohammed Asif Ali. #MohammedAsifAli



Our Page link: https://www.facebook.com/Islam.A.Solution.For.Humanity/